Gift guide
Thanksgiving in a bottle: pie spice, caramel and the twins that cost less
The famous fragrances that smell like the long table, split into courses. Tick the ones you love and find your bottle, and its cheaper twin.
Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26 this year. Long before anyone sits down, the house already smells of it: butter and cinnamon from the oven, something caramelising, a bottle opened early. Plenty of famous perfumes smell of it, and every one below has a cheaper twin.
145
famous fragrances fit the table
1,253
cheaper twins between them
93%
typical saving per 100ml
Our Thanksgiving page picks them by their listed notes and accords: pie spice, gourmand, caramel, praline, warm vanilla, never by hand. Split into courses, the menu looks like this:
- The pie Cinnamon, nutmeg, clove: the spice tin. 95 bottles
- The caramel Caramel, praline, toffee, tonka: dessert, slightly burnt. 79 bottles
- The nightcap Rum, cognac, bourbon: what gets poured after the plates are cleared. 26 bottles
- By the fire Tobacco and soft woods for the end of the evening. 98 bottles
Set your table
Tick the courses you love. We will find the bottles that carry the most of them, and the twin that costs a fraction.
From the 40 most-loved picks. Ranked by courses matched, then by how loved and how copied.
6 bottles on the list carry all four courses at once: Parfums de Marly Althaïr, By Kilian Angels' Share, By Kilian Apple Brandy and Amouage Opus XIV Royal Tobacco. The whole dinner, in one spray.
The most-loved bottle on the table
Of everything that fits, the most loved is Lancôme La Vie Est Belle, at $264 per 100ml. Its best-value twin, Grandeur Elite La Vie Femme, is $20. Slide to see a year of it.
What you would keep
If you get through 2 × 100ml a year
Lancôme La Vie Est Belle
$528
La Vie Femme
$40
Back in your pocket
$488
A note for the host
Food is the guest of honour. Wear a gourmand lightly at the table, one spray, somewhere it warms slowly, and save the boozy and smoky ones for after dinner. If tobacco and vanilla is your season, Tobacco Vanille season has the full story. And the morning after is Black Friday: the biggest savings on famous scents are the same twins at the same prices, no queue required.
Your turn · reader poll
Which course would you wear?






