FRAGDNA

Dupe review · Alexandria Fragrances

Brooklyn Fragrance Lover

Brooklyn Fragrance Lover is Alexandria Fragrances's answer to By Kilian Angels' Share — at 81% less per 100ml.

By Kilian Angels' Share
OriginalAngels' Share$570/100ml
Alexandria Fragrances Brooklyn Fragrance Lover
This dupeBrooklyn Fragrance Lover$110/100ml
Smells like
By Kilian Angels' Share
Price
$109.99
Size
100ml
Per 100ml
$110
Original per 100ml
$570
Made by
Alexandria Fragrances

The FragDNA review

Brooklyn Fragrance Lover: Sweet jam dupe, not Angel’s Share

FragDNA · compiled from 3 reviews and 7 short takes from Parfumo wearers · 21 October 2026

—too early to say
Opening
A vivid burst of apricot‑raspberry jam sweetness topped with a creamy, almost milky veil.
Dry-down
The heart cools into a warm, woody‑spicy accord with faint fig and caramel hints.
Longevity
Six to eight hours on skin, shorter on clothing.
Projection
Moderately close‑to‑skin, a gentle trail rather than a bold sillage.
Best for
Casual daytime wear, spring‑summer, lovers of sweet fruity‑gourmand scents.

Alexandria Fragrances’ Brooklyn Fragrance Lover is marketed as a budget twin of Kilian’s Angels’ Share, offering a dramatically lower price tag – $110 for 100 ml versus the original’s $570. Buyers are drawn by the promise of a luxurious, warm gourmand at a fraction of the cost, hoping to capture the coveted boozy‑spice vibe without breaking the bank.

In practice, the scent opens with a jam‑like fruitiness that most reviewers liken to apricot or raspberry preserves, a direction that diverges sharply from Angels’ Share’s cognac‑spiced start. The dry‑down introduces a modest woody‑spicy character with a whisper of fig and caramel, which some find pleasant but far removed from the original’s sandalwood‑laden, oaky finish. Opinions differ on the fig note, with a few detecting it clearly and others hearing only a vague fruit‑cream blend.

Performance sits in the mid‑range: most users report six to eight hours of wear before the jammy sweetness fades, with a modest projection that stays close to the skin. At its price, the dupe offers decent value for those who enjoy a sweet, fruity‑gourmand for everyday use, but connoisseurs seeking a true Angels’ Share experience will likely be left wanting.

The verdictBrooklyn Fragrance Lover delivers a pleasant, jam‑filled gourmand at an attractive price, yet it strays considerably from the boozy, sandalwood‑rich profile of Angels’ Share. It works well as an affordable, casual sweet scent but falls short as a faithful replica.

What we read: Parfumo wearers · Parfumo.de wearers

6.8/ 10

Strong contender

FragDNA score · on paper

On paper

On paper, Brooklyn Fragrance Lover is a strong bet if you want Angels' Share for less.

Alexandria Fragrances sells it on the name alone — no note list of its own — so the brief is Angels' Share's pyramid, and the closeness votes below are the real test.

At $110 per 100ml it costs 81% less than Angels' Share — the 22nd cheapest of 25 twins we can price.

Value9.0
Evidence7.0

Reviewed on paper: from the notes and strength Alexandria Fragrances publishes, the price per 100ml, and how firmly the match is claimed. How it really smells on skin is what the votes below are for.

What it's built to smell like

The original opens on cognac, turns to cinnamon, Tonka Bean and oak, and settles into praline, vanilla and sandalwood. That is the brief Brooklyn Fragrance Lover is working from.

Top

  • cognac

Heart

  • cinnamon
  • Tonka Bean
  • oak

Base

  • praline
  • vanilla
  • sandalwood
For the one who savors a fireside glass of aged cognac, wrapped in cinnamon, praline and warm vanilla on cold nights.

How it ranks against the other twins

Of the 32 twins of By Kilian Angels' Share we can price, Brooklyn Fragrance Lover is number 22 on price per 100ml.

  1. 01 Fragrance World Cocktail Intense $24/100ml
  2. 02 The Essence Vault Angels Share $32/100ml
  3. 03 The Essence Vault The Essence Vault $32/100ml
  4. 04 The Essence Vault Angels' Share $32/100ml
  5. 05 Bujairami Booz $33/100ml
  6. 06 Palermo Perfumes Angels' Share $33/100ml
  7. 07 Noted Aromas Annecy $33/100ml
  8. 08 Blossom Perfumery 528 $34/100ml
  9. 09 Zimaya Sharaf Blend $35/100ml
  10. 10 The Dupe Spot Angels' Share #306 $36/100ml
All 32 twins of Angels' Share →

More from Alexandria Fragrances

Every Alexandria Fragrances fragrance →

The community

What people say about Brooklyn Fragrance Lover

Rating

—

How close to Angels' Share

—

Would buy again

—

Longevity

Projection

Best in

SpringSummerAutumnWinter

    Questions

    What does Alexandria Fragrances Brooklyn Fragrance Lover smell like?

    It is built to smell like By Kilian Angels' Share — cognac up top, cinnamon, Tonka Bean and oak in the heart, praline, vanilla and sandalwood in the base.

    Is Alexandria Fragrances Brooklyn Fragrance Lover a dupe of By Kilian Angels' Share?

    Yes — Alexandria Fragrances sells it as its version of By Kilian Angels' Share.

    How much cheaper is Alexandria Fragrances Brooklyn Fragrance Lover than By Kilian Angels' Share?

    81% less per 100ml: about $110 per 100ml against $570 for the original.

    Where can I buy Alexandria Fragrances Brooklyn Fragrance Lover?

    It is in stock at $109.99 for 100ml — the link on this page goes straight to the shop.

    The FragDNA Edit · free, weekly

    The twins worth buying,
    before everyone else.

    One email a week: the new dupes that actually get close, the price drops, and the launches already being copied. No spam, no paid picks.

    One email a week · unsubscribe in one click · we never share your address. Privacy