Coconut Cartel

Scentual Obsessions Coconut Cartel lists eight of the twelve notes found in Creed Virgin Island Water – white bergamot, ginger, coconut, hibiscus, ylang‑ylang, white rum, sugar cane and musk – indicating a strong conceptual alignment with the original’s tropical heart. Priced at $150 per 100 ml versus $490 for the Creed, the dupe presents a considerably more affordable entry point for those attracted by this aromatic palette.

The dupe diverges with lime, sicilian mandarin, Indian jasmine and sea salt, while the original retains sicilian lime, mandarin and a classic jasmine. These exclusive ingredients suggest the dupe may lean slightly sharper on citrus and introduce a marine nuance, whereas the original leans toward a more nuanced jasmine character. Neither fragrance’s performance data are available, so the practical impact of these differences remains untested.

The verdictOn paper the dupe captures many of the signature tropical and citrus elements of Virgin Island Water at a fraction of the cost, though it adds sea salt and swaps jasmine variants, meaning it is not a direct replica.

Nobody has reviewed this dupe yet — this compares the published notes and prices. We rewrite it as soon as wearers do.