FRAGDNA

Dupe review · Scentual Obsessions

Sicily

Scentual Obsessions made Sicily with one brief: Xerjoff Naxos — and it costs 52% less per 100ml.

Xerjoff Naxos
OriginalNaxos$290/100ml
Scentual Obsessions Sicily
This dupeSicily$140/100ml
Smells like
Xerjoff Naxos
Price
$41.99
Size
30ml
Per 100ml
$140
Original per 100ml
$290
Made by
Scentual Obsessions

The FragDNA review · on paper

Sicily Offers a Richer Palette at Half the Price

FragDNA · compiled from a comparison on paper — the listed notes and prices; nobody has reviewed it yet · 22 October 2026

—not yet worn
Opening
The opening promises a bright citrus‑spiced bouquet anchored by bergamot, lemon and a hint of lavender, sweetened by honey.
Dry-down
The dry‑down hints at a warm, creamy foundation of vanilla and tonka, softened by the woody‑amber of cashmeran and the subtle spice of tobacco leaf.
Best for
Warm gourmand evenings

Scentual Obsessions Sicily mirrors Xerjoff Naxos in its citrus‑spiced opening, featuring bergamot, lemon and lavender alongside honey and cinnamon. Both fragrances share a vanilla‑sweet base, but the dupe introduces cashmeran for a modern woody‑amber nuance, jasmine sambac for a fresher floral edge, and a tobacco leaf that differs from Naxos’s tobacco note. The inclusion of tonka bean aligns with the original’s tonka, albeit listed separately.

On paper the dupe is priced at $140 per 100 ml, considerably lower than Naxos’s $290, offering a more accessible entry point for those attracted by the shared citrus‑spice‑vanilla theme. No wearer reviews exist yet, so any assessment of performance remains speculative; the comparison here rests solely on the disclosed ingredient lists and price differentials.

The verdictPaper‑wise, Sicily captures many of Naxos’s key citrus and gourmand accords while adding a woody‑amber twist, and does so at roughly half the price. Whether the added notes bridge the gap left by the original’s jasmine and tobacco remains to be seen.

Nobody has reviewed this dupe yet — this compares the published notes and prices. We rewrite it as soon as wearers do.

5.9/ 10

Worth a try

FragDNA score · on paper

On paper

On paper, Sicily is a reasonable bet if you want Naxos for less.

Scentual Obsessions lists 6 of the 9 notes in Naxos's pyramid — bergamot, lavender, lemon, honey and cinnamon and more. What it does not list: jasmine, tobacco and tonka; and it adds cashmeran, jasmine sambac and tobacco leaf of its own.

At $140 per 100ml it costs 52% less than Naxos — the 19th cheapest of 19 twins we can price.

Some wearers dispute how close it gets — the match is the seller's claim, so read the votes before you buy.

Value5.8
Note match6.7
Evidence6.0

Notes compared with Naxos

bergamotlavenderlemonhoneycinnamonvanilla jasminetobaccotonka + cashmeran+ jasmine sambac+ tobacco leaf+ tonka bean

in bothonly in the original+ only in Sicily

Reviewed on paper: from the notes and strength Scentual Obsessions publishes, the price per 100ml, and how firmly the match is claimed. How it really smells on skin is what the votes below are for.

What it's built to smell like

The original opens on bergamot, lavender and lemon, turns to honey, cinnamon and jasmine, and settles into tobacco, tonka and vanilla. That is the brief Sicily is working from.

Top

  • bergamot
  • lavender
  • lemon

Heart

  • honey
  • cinnamon
  • jasmine

Base

  • tobacco
  • tonka
  • vanilla
For nights that deserve gold. Lavender and citrus dissolve into honeyed tobacco, tonka and vanilla — a warm, opulent fougère you can almost taste.

Some fans dispute how close this one gets — it is listed against the original by its seller.

How it ranks against the other twins

Of the 24 twins of Xerjoff Naxos we can price, Sicily is number 19 on price per 100ml.

  1. 01 Noted Aromas Catania $33/100ml
  2. 02 Blossom Perfumery 562 $34/100ml
  3. 03 The Dupe Spot Naxos #289 $36/100ml
  4. 04 Nusuk Ateeq $43/100ml
  5. 05 Lattafa Fakhar Extrait $45/100ml
  6. 06 Maison Asrar Muharib $56/100ml
  7. 07 Maison Asrar Muharib $60/100ml
  8. 08 Maison Kin Regno $60/100ml
  9. 09 AromaPassions Legacy $69/100ml
  10. 10 Dupes.se Luna Fierte French Avenue $70/100ml
All 24 twins of Naxos →

More from Scentual Obsessions

Every Scentual Obsessions fragrance →

The community

What people say about Sicily

Rating

—

How close to Naxos

—

Would buy again

—

Longevity

Projection

Best in

SpringSummerAutumnWinter

    Questions

    What does Scentual Obsessions Sicily smell like?

    It is built to smell like Xerjoff Naxos — bergamot, lavender and lemon up top, honey, cinnamon and jasmine in the heart, tobacco, tonka and vanilla in the base.

    Is Scentual Obsessions Sicily a dupe of Xerjoff Naxos?

    Yes — Scentual Obsessions sells it as its version of Xerjoff Naxos.

    How much cheaper is Scentual Obsessions Sicily than Xerjoff Naxos?

    52% less per 100ml: about $140 per 100ml against $290 for the original.

    Where can I buy Scentual Obsessions Sicily?

    It is in stock at $41.99 for 30ml — the link on this page goes straight to the shop.

    The FragDNA Edit · free, weekly

    The twins worth buying,
    before everyone else.

    One email a week: the new dupes that actually get close, the price drops, and the launches already being copied. No spam, no paid picks.

    One email a week · unsubscribe in one click · we never share your address. Privacy