Dupe review · Noted Aromas
Edinburgh
The Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud profile, from Noted Aromas.
- Smells like
- Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud
- Price
- $32.99
- Size
- 100ml
- Per 100ml
- $33
- Original per 100ml
- —
- Made by
- Noted Aromas
Strong contender
FragDNA score · on paper
The review
On paper, Edinburgh is a strong bet if you want Velvet Rose & Oud for less.
Noted Aromas sells it on the name alone — no note list of its own — so the brief is Velvet Rose & Oud's pyramid, and the closeness votes below are the real test.
At $33 per 100ml it costs 84% less than Velvet Rose & Oud — the 2nd cheapest of 5 twins we can price.
Some wearers dispute how close it gets — the match is the seller's claim, so read the votes before you buy.
Reviewed on paper: from the notes and strength Noted Aromas publishes, the price per 100ml, and how firmly the match is claimed. How it really smells on skin is what the votes below are for.
What it's built to smell like
The original opens on damask rose and clove, turns to oud and praline, and settles into vanilla, amber and musk. That is the brief Edinburgh is working from.
Top
- damask rose
- clove
Heart
- oud
- praline
Base
- vanilla
- amber
- musk
Velvety damask rose smouldering over oud and clove, the house's most seductive bottle.
Some fans dispute how close this one gets — it is listed against the original by its seller.
How it ranks against the other twins
Of the 6 twins of Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud we can price, Edinburgh is number 2 on price per 100ml.
- 01 The Essence Vault Velvet Rose and Oud $32/100ml
- 02 Noted Aromas Edinburgh $33/100ml
- 03 HK Perfumes Opus Noir $64/100ml
- 04 Zoha Aroma Velvet Rose & Oud $108/100ml
- 05 Oil Perfumery Velvet Rose & Oud $133/100ml
- 06 Palermo Perfumes Velvet Rose & Oud $22.75
More from Noted Aromas
Every Noted Aromas fragrance →-
Delphismells like Burberry Goddess $32.99 - A Annecysmells like By Kilian Angels' Share $32.99
- V Venicesmells like By Kilian Love, Don't Be Shy $32.99
- T Tortugasmells like By Kilian Black Phantom $32.99
- M Mombasasmells like Byredo Bal d'Afrique $32.99
- S Sofiasmells like Byredo Gypsy Water $32.99
- L Lenssmells like Byredo Rose of No Man's Land $32.99
- M Mojavesmells like Byredo Mojave Ghost $32.99
The community
What people say about Edinburgh
Rating
—How close to Velvet Rose & Oud
—Would buy again
—Longevity
Projection
Best in
No reviews yet. Be the first to say how it wears.
In the forum
Start a discussion →Questions
What does Noted Aromas Edinburgh smell like?
It is built to smell like Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud — damask rose and clove up top, oud and praline in the heart, vanilla, amber and musk in the base.
Is Noted Aromas Edinburgh a dupe of Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud?
Yes — Noted Aromas sells it as its version of Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud.
Where can I buy Noted Aromas Edinburgh?
It is in stock at $32.99 for 100ml — the link on this page goes straight to the shop.