FRAGDNA

Dupe review · Oil Perfumery

Smoke for the Soul

Oil Perfumery made Smoke for the Soul with one brief: By Kilian Smoke for the Soul.

By Kilian Smoke for the Soul
OriginalSmoke for the SoulBy Kilian
Oil Perfumery Smoke for the Soul
This dupeSmoke for the Soul$125/100ml
Smells like
By Kilian Smoke for the Soul
Price
$74.95
Size
60ml
Per 100ml
$125
Original per 100ml
—
Made by
Oil Perfumery
6.5/ 10

Strong contender

FragDNA score · on paper

The review

Strong contender. That is where Smoke for the Soul lands when you weigh what it costs, what it is made of and how firmly it is matched to Smoke for the Soul.

Oil Perfumery sells it on the name alone — no note list of its own — so the brief is Smoke for the Soul's pyramid, and the closeness votes below are the real test.

At $125 per 100ml it costs 72% less than Smoke for the Soul — the 2nd cheapest of 2 twins we can price.

Value8.0
Evidence7.0

Reviewed on paper: from the notes and strength Oil Perfumery publishes, the price per 100ml, and how firmly the match is claimed. How it really smells on skin is what the votes below are for.

What it's built to smell like

What it is chasing: eucalyptus, mint and ginger up top, cannabis accord and incense in the middle, cedarwood, Tonka Bean and musk underneath — the shape of By Kilian Smoke for the Soul.

Top

  • eucalyptus
  • mint
  • ginger

Heart

  • cannabis accord
  • incense

Base

  • cedarwood
  • Tonka Bean
  • musk
Mentholated green haze over incense and cedar, hazy, herbal and faintly illicit.

How it ranks against the other twins

Of the 3 twins of By Kilian Smoke for the Soul we can price, Smoke for the Soul is number 2 on price per 100ml.

  1. 01 Perfume Parlour Mist Spiritual $89/100ml
  2. 02 Oil Perfumery Smoke for the Soul $125/100ml
  3. 03 Palermo Perfumes Smoke for the Soul $22.75

More from Oil Perfumery

Every Oil Perfumery fragrance →

The community

What people say about Smoke for the Soul

Rating

—

How close to Smoke for the Soul

—

Would buy again

—

Longevity

Projection

Best in

SpringSummerAutumnWinter

    Questions

    What does Oil Perfumery Smoke for the Soul smell like?

    It is built to smell like By Kilian Smoke for the Soul — eucalyptus, mint and ginger up top, cannabis accord and incense in the heart, cedarwood, Tonka Bean and musk in the base.

    Is Oil Perfumery Smoke for the Soul a dupe of By Kilian Smoke for the Soul?

    Yes — Oil Perfumery sells it as its version of By Kilian Smoke for the Soul.

    Where can I buy Oil Perfumery Smoke for the Soul?

    It is in stock at $74.95 for 60ml — the link on this page goes straight to the shop.

    The FragDNA Edit · free, weekly

    The twins worth buying,
    before everyone else.

    One email a week: the new dupes that actually get close, the price drops, and the launches already being copied. No spam, no paid picks.

    One email a week · unsubscribe in one click · we never share your address. Privacy