Dupe review · Palermo Perfumes
Carlisle
Palermo Perfumes made Carlisle with one brief: Parfums de Marly Carlisle.
- Smells like
- Parfums de Marly Carlisle
- Price
- $22.75
- Size
- —
- Per 100ml
- —
- Original per 100ml
- $368
- Made by
- Palermo Perfumes
Strong contender
FragDNA score · on paper
The review
Strong contender. That is where Carlisle lands when you weigh what it costs, what it is made of and how firmly it is matched to Carlisle.
Palermo Perfumes sells it on the name alone — no note list of its own — so the brief is Carlisle's pyramid, and the closeness votes below are the real test.
At $23 it costs 95% less than Carlisle.
Some wearers dispute how close it gets — the match is the seller's claim, so read the votes before you buy.
Reviewed on paper: from the notes and strength Palermo Perfumes publishes, the price per 100ml, and how firmly the match is claimed. How it really smells on skin is what the votes below are for.
What it's built to smell like
What it is chasing: green apple, saffron and nutmeg up top, Tonka Bean, osmanthus and davana in the middle, vanilla, patchouli and opoponax underneath — the shape of Parfums de Marly Carlisle.
Top
- green apple
- saffron
- nutmeg
Heart
- Tonka Bean
- osmanthus
- davana
Base
- vanilla
- patchouli
- opoponax
For the one who wants a spicy apple-and-saffron opening melting into warm tonka, vanilla and patchouli, an opulent bright-meets-dark statement with real presence.
Some fans dispute how close this one gets — it is listed against the original by its seller.
How it ranks against the other twins
Of the 12 twins of Parfums de Marly Carlisle we can price, Carlisle is number 8 on price per 100ml.
- 01 Noted Aromas Hanoi $33/100ml
- 02 The Dupe Spot CARLISLE by PARFUMS DE MARLY #101 (NEW ARRIVAL) $36/100ml
- 03 HK Perfumes Just $89/100ml
- 04 Alexandria Fragrances Hafez 1984 $120/100ml
- 05 Oil Perfumery Carlisle $125/100ml
- 06 Scentual Obsessions 3 Rivers $140/100ml
- 07 The Dua Brand Cumbria $176/100ml
- 08 Palermo Perfumes Carlisle $22.75
- 09 The Dupe Spot PERFUME OIL- #101 Our Duplication of CARLISLE $25.97
- 10 Bujairami Kingpin $32.50
More from Palermo Perfumes
Every Palermo Perfumes fragrance →- R Reflection Mansmells like Amouage Reflection Man $22.75
-
Guidancesmells like Amouage Guidance $22.75 - J Journey Mansmells like Amouage Journey Man $22.75
- E Epic Mansmells like Amouage Epic Man $22.75
- C Crème de Cuirsmells like BDK Parfums Crème de Cuir $22.75
- N Noir for Mensmells like Bath & Body Works Noir for Men $22.75
- C Chinatownsmells like Bond No. 9 Chinatown $22.75
- B Bleecker Streetsmells like Bond No. 9 Bleecker Street $22.75
The community
What people say about Carlisle
Rating
—How close to Carlisle
—Would buy again
—Longevity
Projection
Best in
No reviews yet. Be the first to say how it wears.
In the forum
Start a discussion →Questions
What does Palermo Perfumes Carlisle smell like?
It is built to smell like Parfums de Marly Carlisle — green apple, saffron and nutmeg up top, Tonka Bean, osmanthus and davana in the heart, vanilla, patchouli and opoponax in the base.
Is Palermo Perfumes Carlisle a dupe of Parfums de Marly Carlisle?
Yes — Palermo Perfumes sells it as its version of Parfums de Marly Carlisle.
Where can I buy Palermo Perfumes Carlisle?
It is in stock at $22.75 — the link on this page goes straight to the shop.