What smells like Amouage Guidance 46?

2 alternatives are claimed to share its profile, including Palermo Perfumes Guidance 46, HK Perfumes Earth. FragDNA lists a match only where the seller itself states the inspiration — nothing is inferred from notes or name similarity.

What is the cheapest alternative to Amouage Guidance 46?

Palermo Perfumes Guidance 46, about $23 at Palermo Perfumes. Prices are read from the retailer's own page and re-checked daily.

Do these smell identical to Amouage Guidance 46?

No. They are alternatives the seller says were inspired by it. FragDNA publishes no match percentage, because there is no honest way to measure one — the ranking uses community votes, then how many independent sellers corroborate the pairing, then price.