Head-to-head
Edinburgh vs Velvet Rose & Oud
Noted Aromas built Edinburgh to smell like Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud.
E 
The dupe · Noted Aromas
Edinburgh $32.99 · 100ml≈
The original · Jo Malone London
Velvet Rose & Oud $210 / 100mlPrice per 100ml
The notes it's built on
Top
damask rose and clove
Heart
oud and praline
Base
vanilla, amber and musk
Against the other twins
Edinburgh is number 2 of 6 twins of Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud, on price per 100ml.
- The Essence Vault Velvet Rose and Oud$32/100ml
- Noted Aromas Edinburgh$33/100ml
- HK Perfumes Opus Noir$64/100ml
- Zoha Aroma Velvet Rose & Oud$108/100ml
- Oil Perfumery Velvet Rose & Oud$133/100ml
Is Noted Aromas Edinburgh a dupe of Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud?
Yes — Noted Aromas sells it as its version of Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud.
What notes is Edinburgh built on?
The Jo Malone London Velvet Rose & Oud pyramid: damask rose and clove on top, oud and praline in the heart, vanilla, amber and musk in the base.