Black Friday
Black Friday maths: is a discounted original cheaper than its dupe?
Slide the discount and watch the per-100ml sum. How far a famous bottle would have to fall before it beats its cheapest twin.
Every November the same thought arrives with the sale emails: if the real bottle is 30% off, why buy the copy? It is a fair question, and it has an answer you can work out. Take what an original costs per 100ml, knock off the discount, and set it beside what its cheapest twin costs per 100ml. We ran that sum on 165 fragrances.
165
originals we can price both ways
91%
off the original, typically, to match its cheapest twin
3
would beat their twin at 30% off
Typical = the median. Prices are list prices in our catalogue, compared per 100ml. No shop, no real sale: the discount is hypothetical.
Pick a discount
Slide to the sort of deal you might see. Each row shows the original at that discount against the cheapest twin we can price, both per 100ml. The count underneath covers all 165 originals, not just these 12.
- La Vie Est BelleLancôme
$264$185/100ml Grandeur Elite La Vie Femme$20/100ml Twin still $165 less - Black OpiumYves Saint Laurent
$280$196/100ml Grandeur Elite Optimum Noir$20/100ml Twin still $176 less - Coco MademoiselleChanel
$308$216/100ml Riiffs Bella Rouge$24/100ml Twin still $192 less - Tobacco VanilleTom Ford
$600$420/100ml Copycat Fragrances Tobacco Vanille$29/100ml Twin still $391 less - ErosVersace
$120$84/100ml Riiffs Imperial Blue$28/100ml Twin still $56 less - Baccarat Rouge 540Maison Francis Kurkdjian
$514$360/100ml The Dupe Spot Baccarat Rouge 540 #3$13/100ml Twin still $347 less - AventusCreed
$510$357/100ml Nusuk Ana Al Awwal Silver$17/100ml Twin still $340 less - Good GirlCarolina Herrera
$274$192/100ml Lattafa Bint Hooran$6/100ml Twin still $186 less - Le MaleJean Paul Gaultier
$106$74/100ml Noted Aromas Naples$33/100ml Twin still $41 less - By the FireplaceMaison Margiela
$170$119/100ml Lattafa Raghba Wood Intense$30/100ml Twin still $89 less - Le Male ElixirJean Paul Gaultier
$142$100/100ml Maison Alhambra Glacier Gold$28/100ml Twin still $71 less - Dior Homme IntenseDior
$165$115/100ml Pendora Scents Camaro Homme Intense$22/100ml Twin still $93 less
At 30% off, 3 of 165 originals would cost less per 100ml than their cheapest twin.
Why the maths is so lopsided
Half of the originals here would need 91% or more off before they matched their cheapest twin. 145 of the 165 would need more than 80%. Sales rarely go that deep on famous bottles, and the reason is simple: a twin is not a discounted original. It is a different product built to cost a fraction from the start, with none of the designer's advertising, packaging or name to pay for.
On the shelf above, the hardest to beat is Good Girl, which would need 98% off. The nearest to a fair fight is Le Male, at 69%. At 30% off, none of the 12 comes out ahead.
Against a typical twin, not the cheapest
The cheapest twin is not always the one you would buy. So we ran the sum again against the middle-priced twin of each original, the one halfway down its price list. The typical discount needed falls to 80%. Still deeper than most sales, but the gap narrows. At 50% off, 3 originals would match their typical twin.
And a handful turn the question round entirely: 3 originals are already cheaper per 100ml than any twin we can price, at full price. Sol de Janeiro Cheirosa 71, Afnan 9 PM and Afnan 9 PM Rebel. No discount needed, though each was an inexpensive bottle to begin with.
Three things worth checking in any deal
The size. A big percentage off a small bottle can still cost more per 100ml than a full-price large one. Divide the price by the millilitres and multiply by 100; price per 100ml explains why it is the only fair comparison.
The starting price. A discount is only as good as the price it comes off. Compare the sale price with what the bottle normally costs, not with the number crossed out beside it.
What you are buying. A discounted original is the real thing, and that is worth something. A twin is cheaper and close, sometimes very close, sometimes not; the wearers' scores on each dupe page tell you which.
Your turn · reader poll
How much off would make you buy the original instead of a twin?
For the famous scents with a priced twin, gathered in one place for the season, see Black Friday on FragDNA, and the swaps for the biggest gaps all year round.



